Shrewsbury Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania, a charming borough nestled in the heart of York County. With its rich history, vibrant community, and picturesque landscapes, Shrewsbury offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. Just a short drive from Baltimore and Harrisburg, this delightful town provides easy access to urban amenities while maintaining a serene, suburban atmosphere.

Shrewsbury is known for its friendly residents and strong sense of community. The town features a variety of local shops, restaurants, and parks, making it an ideal place for families and individuals alike. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely stroll through the scenic parks or indulging in a delicious meal at a local eatery, Shrewsbury is a place where you can truly feel at home.

For those looking to invest in a new home, Shrewsbury offers an impressive selection of properties under $500,000. This affordability allows buyers to explore a range of options, from charming single-family homes to modern townhouses, all set against the backdrop of beautiful landscapes and tree-lined streets. Many of these homes boast spacious yards, updated interiors, and easy access to local amenities, making them perfect for families, first-time buyers, or anyone seeking a peaceful retreat.

With a strong sense of community, a rich history, and homes that fit a variety of lifestyles and budgets, Shrewsbury, PA, is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. Come and explore the possibilities of making this delightful town your new home!

Newest Shrewsbury Homes under $500,000

$410,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ PAYK2112860 MLS

Welcome to 261 Prospect Circle, a beautifully updated villa in the sought-after Villas at Shrewsbury community. Rich hardwood floors fill the main level living and dining spaces, and the updated kitchen offers Corian countertops, cherry cabinetry, and a full stainless GE Profile & KitchenAid appliance suite. The eat-in kitchen flows into a sunroom with a slider to the maintenance free deck, and the main floor primary suite features a trey ceiling, walk-in closet, and a bath with a walk-in shower and double sink vanity. A main floor half bath and laundry/mudroom off the two-car garage add everyday convenience. Upstairs, an open loft, two bedrooms with walk-in closets, and a flexible bonus room provide plenty of room to spread out, and the massive full basement adds even more living space plus a built-in office that conveys. Closet space is plentiful throughout, and this villa lives far larger than it appears from the curb. Recent updates include freshly painted upstairs bedrooms, new siding in 2025, 2023 furnace. The condo association takes care of lawn maintenance. Close to Main Street Shrewsbury and I-83, 261 Prospect Circle offers the best of easy, low-maintenance living.

261 Prospect Cir Unit 7, Shrewsbury

$499,000

PAYK2113042 MLS

Welcome to 24 S Main Street…the “house hack” opportunity you’ve been waiting for! Move in to one unit while collecting rents on the other units-those units can pay your mortgage! Your next adventure awaits. This 3 unit multi-family home is nestled along historic S. Main Street on arguably the most charming street in Shrewsbury. This home has been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated combining historic character, flexible living space, and investment potential. With three separate residential units, a detached studio apartment, and two detached garage spaces, this property offers countless possibilities for an owner-occupant, multi-generational living arrangement, or savvy investor. We love our tenants and we do not want to disturb them unnecessarily unless we have to! Pre-Approvals required for showings. Unit 1 referred to as 24 FRONT features 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, and 1 half bath. Unit 2 referred to as 24 BACK offers 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, 1 half bath, plus a flexible office space that could potentially serve as a third bedroom. Unit 3 referred to as Unit 22 features 1 bedroom and 1 full bath. Then there is a separate detached studio apartment with its own full bath, kitchenette, and bedroom. The sellers have poured their heart and soul into this property, completing numerous updates while preserving the character that makes this home so special. Improvements include updated bathrooms, brand-new mini-split systems, new lighting, fresh paint, LVP flooring in select areas, (they purposefully maintained original hardwood flooring in some places), a washer and dryer in each unit, recently pressure-washed and painted exterior, new shutters, and new planter boxes. The property also offers a lovely, long shared backyard—an inviting place to relax, garden, entertain, or simply enjoy the outdoors. This part of Shrewsbury in the cutest! The town has homespun, laid-back vibes, while still having easy and convenient access to I-83. (20 minutes north is York PA, and 20 minutes south is Hunt Valley, MD). Walmart and Saubel's are both conveniently close for everyday shopping and groceries. Shrewsbury has a great community atmosphere with cute hometown parades and the like. Take a stroll to The Village Coffee & Ice Cream four doors down which is housed in what used to be the town’s bank. This is the perfect example of the unique character and small-town charm that surrounds this property. Sellers have NEVER had trouble renting any of the units. There is just too much good about the property. With multiple existing units, separate laundry, updated mechanical systems, a detached studio, garage space, and a desirable location, there is tremendous flexibility here. The sellers do not have to sell and have cared for this property with genuine pride and affection. They would simply love to see it go to the right buyer who will appreciate its history, charm, and incredible potential. If you've been looking for a property that offers both a place to call home and an opportunity to build wealth through real estate, this one deserves a closer look.

24 S Main St, Shrewsbury

$365,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ PAYK2112430 MLS

Lovingly maintained home in Shrewsbury PA. This lovely 3 bedroom 1.5 bath home sits on a .27 acre lot with mature trees and beautiful gardens and landscaping on a dead end street. The home has new HVAC, a newer roof, newer windows, vinyl siding, and so much more. The kitchen is spacious with a breakfast area and plenty of storage. The home has 2 family rooms, a formal dining room, a large 4 season room, and a 2 car garage. Outside features include a covered front porch, a patio with pergola, a shed, and partially fenced back yard. This home is located minutes from all that Shrewsbury and New Freedom have to offer and easy access to I-83

12 Winchester Rd, Shrewsbury

$359,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ PAYK2111700 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully renovated split foyer, updated throughout in 2026. Offering 1,876 sq. ft. of finished living space, this home features four bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and a fully finished lower level. Inside, you'll find luxury vinyl plank flooring, replacement windows that provide plenty of natural light, and a brick fireplace that adds warmth and character to the living space. The updated interior offers a clean, modern feel while maintaining the home's comfortable layout. Outside, the brick exterior, attached garage, driveway, and 0.21-acre lot provide plenty of everyday convenience. With fresh updates throughout and generous living space on both levels, this home is move-in ready and waiting for its next owner.

37 Lisburn Ave, Shrewsbury

$449,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ PAYK2111714 MLS

This charming Raised-Ranch home, thoughtfully renovated in 2017 and 2019, offers a wonderful blend of modern comfort and classic appeal. With three spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms on the main level, this residence is designed for both relaxation and entertaining. The Gourmet Kitchen features upgraded Cabinetry and Granite Countertops, Stainless Steel appliances, and a large island with bar seating. This seamlessly connects to the Dining and Living areas and creates a warm, open atmosphere for gatherings. Natural light floods the home through energy-efficient windows, enhancing the beauty of the hardwood and carpeted floors and offering pleasant views of the surrounding area. Set on a generous 0.61-acre lot, the property boasts beautifully landscaped front and rear yards. Enjoy outdoor living on the screened deck, ideal for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Challenge your visitors to a Horseshoe match on the regulation course and relax around the firepit. Located in a welcoming suburban community, this home is just minutes from local churches, parks, schools, medical facilities and essential public services. There is great potential for in-law quarters with a complete kitchen and full bath, private entry and very few steps for ingress. The neighborhood is known for its friendly atmosphere and community events, making it a wonderful place to connect with neighbors. With ample parking, including an oversized attached garage and a private driveway, this home is ready to embrace your lifestyle. Experience the comfort and convenience of this delightful property, where every detail invites you to make lasting memories. Schedule to see this home right away!

571 E Tolna Rd, Shrewsbury

$369,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ PAYK2111424 MLS

Country Charm meets convenience! This beautifully situated split level home sits on 2.1 acres of mostly cleared, level land, backing to woods. The updated kitchen features stainless steel appliances and granite countertops and a large island overlooking the spacious family room. Three comfortable sized bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms and multiple finished lower-level spaces offer the possibility of a fourth bedroom and plenty of room to live, work and entertain, with endless opportunities. Enjoy the outdoors from the walk out basement patio, deck or approximately 2-year-old above ground pool. Recent upgrades include a 2019 roof, new ceiling fans and newer appliances. Conveniently located near I-83, shopping and dining. Don't miss this private country retreat! Schedule your showing today!

13 Foxtail Ct, Shrewsbury

$278,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ PAYK2111004 MLS

This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage style rancher combines comfortable main floor living with an improved basement and lower level oversized one car garage. The interior is showing its age a little, but the outdoor space offers room to unwind, garden, or gather with friends and family. Tucked into an established Shrewsbury neighborhood, you'll enjoy convenient access to local shops, restaurants, parks, and I-83. An affordable opportunity to move in and make this one your own. HUD Homes are sold As-is.

39 Clearview Dr, Shrewsbury

$349,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ PAYK2110246 MLS

Welcome to 12 Virginia Avenue in Shrewsbury, a spacious and inviting four-bedroom home offering timeless character, generous living areas, and an exceptional setting on a beautiful .4155-acre corner lot. From the moment you arrive, the home makes a warm first impression with its classic brick-and-siding exterior, mature landscaping, covered front entry, expansive driveway, and oversized two-car garage. Inside, you'll find a flexible and comfortable floor plan designed to accommodate both everyday living and entertaining. The main level offers multiple gathering spaces, including a spacious family room, a separate living room or den, an eat-in kitchen, and a formal dining area. Hardwood and tile flooring extend through much of the home, adding warmth, durability, and classic appeal. The kitchen features abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, stainless-steel appliances, and a center island with casual seating. Its connection to the dining area creates an easy flow for meals, conversation, and entertaining, while the nearby formal dining space provides additional room for hosting family and friends. The family room offers plenty of space to relax and unwind, while the separate living room or den adds valuable versatility for a home office, reading room, playroom, media space, or additional sitting area. A convenient half bath completes the main level. Upstairs, the home features four bedrooms and a full hall bath. The primary bedroom is generously sized and includes a walk-in closet, while the additional bedrooms provide excellent flexibility for family, guests, hobbies, or office space. The full bath includes a dual-sink vanity, helping make busy mornings more convenient. The lower level adds even more function with basement space, a fireplace, substantial utility and storage areas, and a walk-out Bilco door providing convenient exterior access. Outdoor living is another standout feature of this property. The expansive yard offers plenty of room for get-togethers, gardening, recreation, pets, or simply relaxing beneath the mature shade trees. Multiple patio areas create inviting spaces for grilling, outdoor dining, and entertaining, while the established landscaping, garden areas, and open lawn give the property a peaceful and welcoming feel. The oversized two-car garage provides excellent parking, storage, and workspace, while the corner-lot setting enhances the sense of space and openness around the home. Conveniently located just minutes from the Shrewsbury interchange of I-83, this home offers easy access for commuting to destinations throughout both Pennsylvania and Maryland. Whether you're traveling north toward York and Harrisburg or south toward Maryland, the location makes everyday travel simple and convenient. With four bedrooms, one-and-a-half baths, multiple living spaces, hardwood and tile floors, a basement fireplace, an oversized two-car garage, a .4155-acre corner lot, and a highly convenient location, 12 Virginia Avenue offers the space, versatility, and lifestyle buyers are looking for in Shrewsbury.

12 Virginia Ave, Shrewsbury

$385,500

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ PAYK2109820 MLS

Welcome home to this beautiful 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offering comfortable living spaces and plenty of room to relax and entertain. The main level features a cozy living room with an electric fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, and a convenient half bath. Upstairs, you’ll find three bedrooms and a full bath. The finished lower-level basement provides additional living space, complete with a wood-burning fireplace—perfect for movie nights, gatherings, or simply unwinding. Enjoy outdoor living in the fenced backyard with a shed, along with the convenience of a 2-car attached front-entry garage. Schedule your tour today and see all this home has to offer!

25 W Maple Ave, Shrewsbury

Start Your Search

INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE, BUT NOT GUARANTEED. Listings courtesy of WEST PENN MULTILIST, INC.

Listings courtesy of Pike Wayne Association of Realtors as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.